Title:Semantic Drift in Bug Resolution: How Behavioral Signals Propagate from Reports to Tests and Patches

Abstract:Desc2Fix is a framework for measuring semantic alignment between bug reports, triggering tests, and developer-written fixes. Alignment is operationalized through structured behavioral anchors (e.g., reproduction steps, API/exception cues, expected vs. actual behavior), deterministic similarity metrics (ROUGE, SBERT, CodeBERT, OpenAI embeddings), and LLM-based judgments grounded in coverage, correctness, and specificity. Our analysis covers 2,857 report-test-patch triplets from Defects4J and SWT-Bench using two widely adopted instruction-tuned LLMs from distinct model families. LLMs reliably extract structured signals (up to 90% completeness) and exhibit strong cross-model consistency, yielding a stable semantic input contract for downstream reasoning. However, alignment is highly representation-sensitive: lexical similarity alone is insufficient, full diffs provide the most stable basis for judging report-patch correspondence, and structured summaries trade surface overlap for stronger correspondence at the level of individual actions and entities. Across more than 182,000 LLM-based alignment judgments, both models exhibit systematic optimism relative to humans (1-2 points on 5-point scales) and only modest rank agreement, motivating bias-aware evaluation. Behavioral alignment is measurable but not reducible to similarity, and structured anchors combined with embedding-based proxies provide reproducible signals for ranking and filtering tests and patches. Desc2Fix could support more reliable test generation, fault localization, patch ranking, and bug report authoring.