-
The exact Spearman rho-footrule region via optimal transport with applications to finite rankings, mixability, and Chatterjee's rank correlation
Authors:
Jonathan Ansari,
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
We solve the open problem of determining the maximal value of Spearman's rho when Spearman's footrule is prescribed, thereby completing the exact attainable region of these two quantities. To prove this result, we reformulate the underlying copula optimization problem as an optimal transport problem with a linear moment constraint and construct the unique optimal coupling through a matching feasib…
▽ More
We solve the open problem of determining the maximal value of Spearman's rho when Spearman's footrule is prescribed, thereby completing the exact attainable region of these two quantities. To prove this result, we reformulate the underlying copula optimization problem as an optimal transport problem with a linear moment constraint and construct the unique optimal coupling through a matching feasible dual potential and its contact set. Equivalently, this coupling minimizes the variance of $|U-V|$ among all couplings of $U,V\sim\mathcal{U}(0,1)$ with prescribed mean $\mathbb{E}|U-V|$. Our main result admits several applications: First, in the context of finite rankings, we obtain an improved Cauchy--Schwarz inequality between Spearman's footrule distance and the associated quadratic rank difference. Second, in the framework of generalized mixability, we characterize the attainable constant values of $|U'+V'|$, for $U',V'\sim\mathcal{U}(-1/2,1/2)$, and determine the minimal quadratic deviation for a given mean. Third, we derive explicit bounds relating Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ(X,Y)$, which can detect complex functional dependence of $Y$ on $X$, to the copula correlation ratio--a rank-based fraction of explained variance--by exploiting their conditional i.i.d. representations in terms of Spearman's footrule and Spearman's rho.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2026;
originally announced August 2026.
-
The exact region determined by Kendall's tau, Spearman's footrule and Blomqvist's beta
Authors:
Jacob Israel Orenday Lares,
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
We determine the exact region $Ω_{τ,φ,β}:=\{(τ(C),φ(C),β(C)):C\in\mathcal{C}\}$ of possible joint values of Kendall's tau, Spearman's footrule and Blomqvist's beta over the class $\mathcal{C}$ of all bivariate copulas. The region consists precisely of all triples $(t,p,b)$ satisfying $-1\le b\le 1$, $\frac{3}{16}(1+b)^2-\frac12\le p\le 1-\frac38(1-b)^2$ and…
▽ More
We determine the exact region $Ω_{τ,φ,β}:=\{(τ(C),φ(C),β(C)):C\in\mathcal{C}\}$ of possible joint values of Kendall's tau, Spearman's footrule and Blomqvist's beta over the class $\mathcal{C}$ of all bivariate copulas. The region consists precisely of all triples $(t,p,b)$ satisfying $-1\le b\le 1$, $\frac{3}{16}(1+b)^2-\frac12\le p\le 1-\frac38(1-b)^2$ and $\frac43 p-\frac13\le t\le \frac23 p+\frac13$. In other words, the known exact $(φ,β)$- and $(τ,φ)$-regions already characterize the joint region, so that, once the value of Spearman's footrule is fixed, Blomqvist's beta imposes no additional sharp restriction on the possible values of Kendall's tau. The proof is constructive: two one-parameter families of shuffles of $M$ realize the extreme values of Kendall's tau along the lower boundary of the $(φ,β)$-region, ordinal sums spread these families through the whole region, and the vertical fibres are filled using the biaffinity of the concordance function. We further show that $Ω_{τ,φ,β}$ is convex with rectangular fixed-footrule sections, identify an affine symmetry of its fibres about $τ=φ$, and compute its volume, which equals $\frac{31}{40}$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2026;
originally announced July 2026.
-
The exact region between Chatterjee's $ξ$ and Blomqvist's $β$
Authors:
Jacob Israel Orenday Lares,
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
We determine the exact attainable region of the pair $(ξ(C),β(C))$ formed by Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ and Blomqvist's $β$ over the class of all bivariate copulas and show that it is given by $\{(x,y)\in[0,1]\times[-1,1]: |y|^3\le 2x\}.$ The left boundary $ξ=|β|^3/2$ is attained by an explicit two-strip family $(L_b)_{b\in[-1,1]}$ obtained by perturbing independence with a signed tent func…
▽ More
We determine the exact attainable region of the pair $(ξ(C),β(C))$ formed by Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ and Blomqvist's $β$ over the class of all bivariate copulas and show that it is given by $\{(x,y)\in[0,1]\times[-1,1]: |y|^3\le 2x\}.$ The left boundary $ξ=|β|^3/2$ is attained by an explicit two-strip family $(L_b)_{b\in[-1,1]}$ obtained by perturbing independence with a signed tent function $g_b$ centered at the median. We derive several properties of this copula family including the formulas for its density and rank correlation measures, as well as positive and negative dependence properties. The right boundary $ξ=1$ is attained for every admissible value of $β$ by deterministic measure-preserving copulas, and the full region is obtained by taking convex mixtures of the left- and right-boundary copulas with fixed $β$ and using the continuity of $ξ$ along these mixtures. We also record the exact regions in several natural subclasses of copulas.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2026;
originally announced June 2026.
-
Kendall and Spearman bounds for Chatterjee's rank correlation under positive dependence
Authors:
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
We compare Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ with Kendall's $τ$ and Spearman's $ρ$ under positive-dependence assumptions on bivariate copulas. Our main technical contribution is a sharp order-violation bound for two stochastically ordered distribution functions. This local inequality controls each conditional order-violation probability appearing in Kendall's tau by the cross-rank variance functio…
▽ More
We compare Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ with Kendall's $τ$ and Spearman's $ρ$ under positive-dependence assumptions on bivariate copulas. Our main technical contribution is a sharp order-violation bound for two stochastically ordered distribution functions. This local inequality controls each conditional order-violation probability appearing in Kendall's tau by the cross-rank variance functionals that determine Chatterjee's rank correlation. As a consequence, we prove the sharp Kendall bound $ξ(C)\leq τ(C)$ for every stochastically increasing copula $C$. The bound is best possible: ordinal sums of product copulas attain equality. We also prove that the weaker left-tail decreasing (LTD) and right-tail increasing (RTI) conditions jointly imply the Spearman bound $ξ(C)\leq ρ(C)$, with equality if and only if $C$ is either the independence or comonotonicity copula. Finally, checkerboard examples show that LTD or RTI alone does not imply $ξ(C)\leqρ(C)$, that LTD and RTI together do not imply $ξ(C)\leqτ(C)$, and that both bounds are directional for $ξ$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2026;
originally announced June 2026.
-
The exact region between Chatterjee's and Blest's rank correlations
Authors:
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
Exact regions between rank correlations describe the set of all pairs of values that two dependence measures can attain simultaneously on the same copula and thus yield sharp inequalities between them. In this paper, we determine the exact region between Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ and Blest's rank correlation $ν$ over the class of all bivariate copulas. Our approach is based on a constraine…
▽ More
Exact regions between rank correlations describe the set of all pairs of values that two dependence measures can attain simultaneously on the same copula and thus yield sharp inequalities between them. In this paper, we determine the exact region between Chatterjee's rank correlation $ξ$ and Blest's rank correlation $ν$ over the class of all bivariate copulas. Our approach is based on a constrained optimization problem whose solution is characterized by Karush--Kuhn--Tucker conditions. This leads to a novel extremal copula family that uniquely traces the boundary of the region. For this family, we derive closed-form expressions for both $ξ$ and $ν$, which provide an explicit parametrization of the exact attainable region.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2026;
originally announced March 2026.
-
On the exact region between Chatterjee's rank correlation and Spearman's footrule
Authors:
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
Chatterjee's rank correlation \(ξ\) has emerged as a popular measure quantifying the strength of directed functional dependence between random variables $X$ and $Y$. If $X$ and $Y$ are continuous, $ξ$ equals Spearman's footrule~\(ψ\) for the Markov product of the copula induced by $(X,Y)$ and its transpose. We analyze the relationship between these two measures more in depth by studying the attain…
▽ More
Chatterjee's rank correlation \(ξ\) has emerged as a popular measure quantifying the strength of directed functional dependence between random variables $X$ and $Y$. If $X$ and $Y$ are continuous, $ξ$ equals Spearman's footrule~\(ψ\) for the Markov product of the copula induced by $(X,Y)$ and its transpose. We analyze the relationship between these two measures more in depth by studying the attainable region of possible pairs \((ξ, ψ)\) over all bivariate copulas. In particular, we show that for given $ξ$, the maximal possible value of $ψ$ is uniquely attained by a Fréchet copula. As a by-product of this and a known result for Markov products of copulas, we obtain that \(ξ\leψ\le \sqrtξ\) characterizes the exact region of stochastically increasing copulas. Regarding the minimal possible value of \(ψ\) for given \(ξ\), we give a lower bound based on Jensen's inequality and construct a two-parameter copula family that comes comparably close.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
The exact region and an inequality between Chatterjee's and Spearman's rank correlations
Authors:
Jonathan Ansari,
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
The rank correlation ξ(X,Y), recently established by Sourav Chatterjee and already popular in the statistics literature, takes values in [0,1], where 0 characterizes independence of X and Y, and 1 characterizes perfect dependence of Y on X. Unlike concordance measures such as Spearman's ρ, which capture the degree of positive or negative dependence, ξquantifies the strength of functional dependenc…
▽ More
The rank correlation ξ(X,Y), recently established by Sourav Chatterjee and already popular in the statistics literature, takes values in [0,1], where 0 characterizes independence of X and Y, and 1 characterizes perfect dependence of Y on X. Unlike concordance measures such as Spearman's ρ, which capture the degree of positive or negative dependence, ξquantifies the strength of functional dependence. In this paper, we study the attainable set of pairs (ξ(X,Y),ρ(X,Y)). The resulting ξ-\r{ho}-region is a convex set whose boundary is characterized by a novel family of absolutely continuous, asymmetric copulas having a diagonal band structure. Moreover, we prove that ξ(X,Y)\leq|ρ}(X,Y)| whenever Y is stochastically increasing or decreasing in X, and we identify the maximal difference ρ(X,Y)-ξ(X,Y) as exactly 0.4. Our proofs rely on a convex optimization problem under various equality and inequality constraints, as well as on ordering properties for ξand ρ. Our results contribute to a better understanding of Chatterjee's rank correlation, which typically yields substantially smaller values than Spearman's ρwhen quantifying positive dependencies. In particular, when interpreting the values of Chatterjee's rank correlation on the scale of ρ, the quantity \sqrtξ appears to be more appropriate.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2026; v1 submitted 18 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Measures of association for approximating copulas
Authors:
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
This paper studies closed-form expressions for multiple association measures of copulas commonly used for approximation purposes, including Bernstein, shuffle--of--min, checkerboard and check--min copulas. In particular, closed-form expressions are provided for the recently popularized Chatterjee's $ξ$, which quantifies the dependence between two random variables. Given an absolutely continuous bi…
▽ More
This paper studies closed-form expressions for multiple association measures of copulas commonly used for approximation purposes, including Bernstein, shuffle--of--min, checkerboard and check--min copulas. In particular, closed-form expressions are provided for the recently popularized Chatterjee's $ξ$, which quantifies the dependence between two random variables. Given an absolutely continuous bivariate copula $C$ with TP$_2$ density and approximating $n\times n$-checkerboard copula $C_n$, we show that $ξ(C_n) \le ξ(C)$ with $ξ(C_n) \to ξ(C)$ as $n\to\infty$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2026; v1 submitted 12 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Dependence properties of bivariate copula families
Authors:
Jonathan Ansari,
Marcus Rockel
Abstract:
Motivated by recently investigated results on dependence measures and robust risk models, this paper provides an overview of dependence properties of many well-known bivariate copula families, where the focus is on the Schur order for conditional distributions, which has the fundamental property that minimal elements characterize independence and maximal elements characterize perfect directed depe…
▽ More
Motivated by recently investigated results on dependence measures and robust risk models, this paper provides an overview of dependence properties of many well-known bivariate copula families, where the focus is on the Schur order for conditional distributions, which has the fundamental property that minimal elements characterize independence and maximal elements characterize perfect directed dependence. We give conditions on copulas that imply the Schur ordering of the associated conditional distribution functions. For extreme-value copulas, we prove the equivalence of the lower orthant order, the Schur order for conditional distributions, and the pointwise order of the associated Pickands dependence functions. Further, we provide several tables and figures that list and illustrate various positive dependence and monotonicity properties of copula families, in particular, from classes of Archimedean, extreme-value, and elliptical copulas. Finally, for Chatterjee's rank correlation, which is consistent with the Schur order for conditional distributions, we give some new closed-form formulas in terms of the parameter of the underlying copula family.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2024; v1 submitted 26 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.