Gauss curvature flow to the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problemThanks:Β 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification: 52A20 35K96 58J35.
Abstract.
Recently, Huang and Qin [15] introduced the Gaussian chord measure and -Gaussian chord measure by variational methods. Meanwhile, they posed Gaussian chord Minkowski problem for and used variational methods to obtain an origin-symmetric normalized measure solution for the Gaussian chord Minkowski problem. The smooth solution, up to now, to the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem is still open.
Motivated by the forgoing works by Huang and Qin in [15], we propose in the present paper the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem and log-Gaussian chord Minkowski problem, and obtain the smooth even solutions to these two types of problems by the method of a Gauss curvature flow.
Key words and phrases:Β
Gauss curvature flow; -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem; Monge-Ampère equation1. Introduction and main results
In the past 30 years, the Minkowski problem has played an important role in the study of convex geometry, and the research of Minkowski problem has promoted the development of fully nonlinear partial differential equations. The classical Minkowski problem argues the existence, uniqueness and regularity of a convex body whose surface area measure is equal to a pre-given Borel measure on the sphere. If the given measure has a positive continuous density, the Minkowski problem can be seen as the problem of prescribing the Gauss curvature in differential geometry. With the emergence of surface measure, the Minkowski problem has also been proposed. In particularly, the ()-Minkowski problem is extremely important, because it contains some special versions, such as when , it is the classical Minkowski problem; when , the critical case which is called cone volume measure, the Minkowski problem for cone volume measure is the log-Minkowski problem [3]; when , it corresponds to the centro-affine Minkowski problem [34]; the -Minkowski problem with was first proposed and studied by Lutwak [23], whose solution plays a key role in establishing the -affine Sobolev inequality [12, 24].
With the development of Minkowski problems, scholars have proposed some types of Minkowski problems. We know that the different geometric measures are corresponding to different Minkowski type problems. For instance, Xiao [32] prescribed capacitary curvature measures on planar convex domains: If a given finite, nonnegative Borel measure has centroid at the origin and its supp() does not comprise any pair of antipodal points, then, there is a unique (up to translation) convex, nonempty, open set such that , where is -capacitary curvature measure of with .
Recently, a theory analogous to the one for the Minkowski problem was introduced by Lutwak, Xi, Yang, and Zhang [25], the volume is replaced by () chord integrals and surface area measure is replaced by the differential of () chord integrals which is defined chord measure. Based on chord measure, they posed and solved chord Minkowski problem and chord log-Minkowski problem (partly solved). Interestingly, when , the chord measure recovers surface area measure, and when , it is the area measure . For the chord Minkowski problem, Xi, Yang, Zhang and Zhao [31] used variational methods gave a measure solution when and in the symmetric case. Guo, Xi and Zhao [11] also obtained a measure solution for by similar methods without the symmetric assumption. In addition, authors [33] posed the Orlicz chord Minkowski problem and obtained smooth solutions by a Gauss curvature flow. When , the chord Minkowski problem is the Minkowski problem. For other references with respect to the chord Minkowski problem, please refer to [13, 14, 19, 26].
Huang, Xi and Zhao [16] extended the classical Minkowski problem in to the Gaussian probability space, where the volume and surface area measure in Euclidean space were replaced by Gaussian volume and Gaussian surface measure, respectively. Then the Gaussian Minkowski problem was posed and provided a sufficient condition for the existence of solution. Later, Liu [20] extended the Gaussian Minkowski problem to form, when , a sufficient condition for the existence and uniqueness of origin-symmetric weak solution was given. Moreover, Feng, Hu and Xu [9] provided the existence of symmetric (resp. asymmetric) solutions to the problem for (resp. ). Furthermore, Sheng and Xue [30] obtained smooth solutions by method of Gauss curvature flow for and to normalized Gaussian Minkowski problem and and to Gaussian Minkowski problem. Contrary to classical surface area measure, the Gaussian surface measure is neither translationally invariant nor homogeneous. These special properties make the Gaussian Minkowski problem quite differ from the classical Minkowski problem, which has an interest on its own.
Very recently, based on chord integral and Gaussian probability space, Huang and Qin [15] generalized the chord integrals to Gaussian probability space for . In the case of , the Gaussian chord integral is defined by
| (1.1) |
Furthermore, they established () the variational formula of Gaussian chord integral with () Minkowski sum. Here, we first state the variational formula for .
Theorem 1.1.
[15, Theorem 4.3]Β Β Β Β Let and . Suppose that is a continuous function and is given by
where uniformly on , as . If
is the Wulff shape of , it holds
Then
where
| (1.2) |
and
Next, a similar result holds for the -combination perturbation of the supporting function, which is stated in the following theorem.
Theorem 1.2.
[15, Theorem 4.4]Β Β Β Β Let , and . Suppose that is a continuous function and is given by
and is the Wulff shape of , it holds
Then
| (1.3) |
where
| (1.4) |
In fact, we can directly obtain Theorem 1.2 by replacing with in Theorem 1.1. When , (1.3) correspondings to the Gaussian chord measure in Theorem 1.1.
As for the -Minkowski perturbation, the variational formula of nonlocal function in Gaussian probability space is obtained in the following Theorem.
Theorem 1.3.
[15, Theorem 4.5]Β Β Β Β Let and . Suppose that is a continuous function and is given by
where, uniformly on , as . If is the Wulff shape of , it holds
Then
| (1.5) |
where
| (1.6) |
With the help of variational formula (1.3), we can propose the normalized -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem for .
The -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem. Let , and be a finite Borel measure on , under what necessary and sufficient conditions, does there exist a unique convex body and positive constant so that
| (1.7) |
From [15, Proposition 3.7], we know that is absolutely continuous with respect to the surface measure . If the given measure is absolutely continuous with respect to the spherical Lebesgue measure, that is, has a density function is smooth, then, solving problem (1.7) can be equivalently viewed as solving the following normalized Monge-Ampère equation from the (1.4) for on .
| (1.8) |
When , the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem is the Gaussian chord Minkowski problem which was first studied by Huang and Qin [15], they obtained an origin-symmetric normalized measure solution by variational method.
Similar to cone volume measure, we call cone-Gaussian chord measure. The Minkowski problem prescribing cone-Gaussian chord measures is:
The log-Gaussian chord Minkowski problem. Let and be a finite Borel measure on , under what necessary and sufficient conditions, does there exist a unique convex body and positive constant so that
| (1.9) |
The partial differential equation associated with (1.9) is a new type of Monge-Ampère equation from (1.6) on ,
| (1.10) |
In this paper, we will study the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem and give the existence of smooth even solutions for (1.8) with and by the method of a Gauss curvature flow. In addition, we also provide a smooth even solution to log-Gaussian chord Minkowski problem to (1.10). The Gauss curvature flow was first introduced and studied by Firey [10] to model the shape change of worn stones. It can mainly be used to study the existence of smooth solutions to the famous Minkowski (type) problems. For instances, Chen, Huang and Zhao [6] obtained smooth even solutions to the dual Minkowski problem by the method of Gauss curvature flow. Liu and Lu [21] used a Gauss curvature flow to solve dual Orlicz-Minkowski problem and obtained its smooth solutions. Since then, various problems of Gauss curvature flows have been extensively studied, see examples [2, 4, 5, 8, 18, 22] and the references therein.
Remark 1.4.
From the definitions of the -combination perturbation and log-Minkowski perturbation of the support function, we konw that the log-Minkowski perturbation is the limit form of the combination perturbation when tends to . In this sense, the variational formula (1.3) and (1.5) belong to different categories, then, the corresponding -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem (1.7) is different from log-Gaussian chord Minkowski problem (1.9). However, when we transform (1.7) to equivalent form equation (1.8) and (1.9) to (1.10), from the perspective of the equation, these two problems can be considered unifiedly. To this end, we can unifiedly construct the following curvature flow to solve the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem for and log-Gaussian chord Minkowski problem for the critical case.
Let be a smooth, closed and origin-symmetric strictly convex hypersurface in . We consider the long-time existence and convergence of the following Gauss curvature flow which is a family of convex hypersurfaces parameterized by smooth maps satisfying the initial value problem
where is the Gauss curvature of hypersurface , is the outer unit normal at , represents standard inner product of and , and is given by
where and are the radial function and support function of the convex hypersurface , respectively.
Remark 1.5.
Theorem 1.6.
Suppose , , be a smooth, closed and origin-symmetric strictly convex hypersurface in and be a positive smooth even function on . Then, the flow (1) has a unique smooth solution to the for . When , there is a subsequence of converges in to a smooth, closed, origin-symmetric and strictly convex hypersurface , whose support function satisfies (1.8) for and (1.10) for .
This paper is organized as follows. We collect background materials in Section 2. In Section 3, we give the parameterized form of flow (1) by support function and discuss properties of two important functionals along the flow (1). In Section 4, we give the priori estimates for the solution to the flow (1). We obtain the convergence of the flow and complete the proof of Theorem 1.6 in Section 5.
2. Preliminaries
In this section, we give a brief review of some relevant notions about convex bodies and recall some basic properties of convex hypersurfaces that readers may refer to [29] and a book of Schneider [27].
2.1. Convex bodies
Let be the -dimensional Euclidean space, let be the Euclidean norm of . The unit sphere in is denoted by , is the volume of the unit ball. For , denotes the -dimensional Hausdorff measure in . In integrals with respect to , we often abbreviate by . Similarly, in integrals over the unite sphere , instead of we write . is the -dimensional Hausdorff measure with respect to Gaussian density function , .
Assume that be a smooth, closed and strictly convex hypersurface containing the origin in its interior. The support function of convex body is defined by
and the radial function of with respect to is defined by
For a compact convex subset and , the intersection of a supporting hyperplane with , at is given by
A boundary point of which only has one supporting hyperplane is called a regular point, otherwise, it is a singular point. The set of singular points is denoted as , it is well known that has spherical Lebesgue measure 0.
For , its Gauss map is represented by
Correspondingly, for a Borel set , its inverse Gauss map is denoted by ,
Specially, for a convex hypersurface of class , then, the support function of β¦ can be stated as
Moreover, the gradient of satisfies
For the Borel set , its surface area measure is defined as
2.2. Convex hypersurface
Suppose that is parameterized by the inverse Gauss map , that is . Then, the support function of can be computed by
| (2.1) |
where is the outer normal of at . Let be an orthonormal frame on , denote by the standard metric on the sphere . Differentiating (2.1), there has
since is tangent to at , thus,
By differentiating (2.1) twice, the second fundamental form of can be computed in terms of the support function,
| (2.2) |
where denotes the second order covariant derivative with respect to . The induced metric matrix of can be derived by Weingartenβs formula,
| (2.3) |
The principal radii of curvature are the eigenvalues of the matrix . When considering a smooth local orthonormal frame on , by virtue of (2.2) and (2.3), there has
| (2.4) |
Then, the Gauss curvature of is given by
| (2.5) |
3. Geometric flow and its associated functionals
In this section, we shall introduce the geometric flow and its associated functionals for solving the -Gaussian chord Minkowski problem. For convenience, the Gauss curvature flow is restated here. Let be a smooth, closed and origin symmetric strictly convex hypersurface in and be a positive smooth even function on . We consider the following Gauss curvature flow
where is the Gauss curvature of the hypersurface at , is the unit outer normal vector of at , represents standard inner product of and , and is given by
| (3.3) |
Taking the scalar product of both sides of the equation and of the initial condition in (3) by , by means of the definition of support function (2.1), we describe the flow equation associated with the support function as follows
Next, we investigate the characteristic of Guassian chord integral along the flow (3). Letβs list a fact firstly (see e.g. [21]).
| (3.6) |
Lemma 3.1.
For , , the is unchanged with regard to Eq. (3), namely,
Proof.
For the convenience of discussing Gauss curvature flow (3), we introduce a following functional for any ,
| (3.8) |
where is the support function of and . When , we write
| (3.9) |
Lemma 3.2.
Proof.
Firstly, we prove , by (3.8), (3.3), (3), (3.6) and , we obtain the following result,
By the equality condition of HΓΆlder inequality, we know that the above equality holds if and only if , i.e.,
4. Priori estimates
In this section, we establish the and estimates for the solutions to Eq. (3). In the following of this paper, we always assume that is a smooth, closed and origin-symmetric strictly convex hypersurface in , is a smooth even solution to Eq. (3) with the initial the support function of . Here, is the maximal time for which the smooth solution exists to Eq. (3).
4.1. estimates
In order to complete the estimate, we firstly need to introduce the following Lemma which was proven by Chen and Li [7] for convex bodies.
Lemma 4.1.
[7, Lemma 2.6] Let , and be respectively support function and radial function of , and and be two points such that and . Then,
Remark 4.2.
The results in Lemma 4.1 be true for any , for example, we can write
Lemma 4.3.
Assume , be a smooth solution to the flow (3) in and is a positive smooth even function on . Then, there is a positive constant independents of such that
| (4.1) |
| (4.2) |
Here, and are the support function and radial function of , respectively.
Proof.
We only give proof of (4.1), and (4.2) can be obtained by the first conclusion of Lemma 4.1 and (4.1).
Firstly, we prove the upper bound of (4.1). From monotonicity of in Lemma 3.2 and the second result of Lemma 4.1, there is following result for ,
then,
where, for any . Here, is a positive constant independents from .
Similarly, when , we have
then,
Here, and be positive constants independent on .
To prove the lower bound of , we use the contradiction. Let us assume that be a sequence such that is not uniformly bounded away from , i.e., as . On the other hand, making use of the upper bound, by Blaschke-Selection theorem, there is a subsequence in , for convenience, which is still denoted by , such that as , where is a origin-symmetric convex body. Then, we obtain . This implies that is contained in a lower-dimensional subspace in . This can lead to as almost everywhere with respect to the spherical Lebesgue measure. According to bounded convergence theorem and formula (3.7), we can derive
However, Lemma 3.1 shows that
which is a contradiction. It follows that has a uniform lower bound. Therefore, we complete estimate of Lemma 4.3. β
Lemma 4.4.
Let , be a smooth solution to the flow (3) in and is a positive smooth even function on . Then, there is a positive constant independents of such that
| (4.3) |
and
| (4.4) |
Proof.
Lemma 4.5.
Suppose , be a smooth solution to the flow (3) in and is a positive smooth even function on . There always exists a positive constant independents of , such that
4.2. estimate
In this subsection, we establish the upper and lower bounds of principal curvature. This will shows that Eq. (3) is uniformly parabolic. The technique used in this proof was first introduced by Tso [28] to derive the upper bound of the Gauss curvature.
By Lemma 4.3 and Lemma 4.4, if is a smooth even solution of Eq. (3) on and is positive smooth even function on , then along the flow (3) for , and are smooth functions whose ranges are within some bounded domain and bounded interval , respectively. Here and depend only on the upper and lower bounds of on .
Lemma 4.6.
For and , assume be a smooth solution to the flow (3) in and is a positive smooth even function on . There is a positive constant depending on , , and , such that the principal curvatures of , , are bounded from above and below, satisfying
Proof.
The proof is divided into two parts: in the first part, we derive an upper bound for the Gauss curvature ; in the second part, we give an estimate of bound above for the principal radii .
Step 1: Prove .
Firstly, we construct the following auxiliary function,
where
For any fixed , we assume that is the spatial maximum of . Then at , we have
| (4.7) |
and from (4.7), at , we also get
| (4.8) |
From (4.8), we obtain
hence,
| (4.9) |
At , we also have
| (4.10) | ||||
Here, we firstly compute . Recall (4.5), we know that for ,
Then,
| (4.11) |
where , , at , there is
Therefore, from Lemma 4.3 and (4.11), we can obtain
| (4.12) |
By and is a maximum point of , we obtain
| (4.13) |
From (4.1), (4.2), (4.6), (4.12) and (4.13), we can get
| (4.14) |
For , (4.1), (4.6) and (4.12) tell us that
| (4.15) |
We use (2.5), (4.9) and recall may give
| (4.16) |
where the last inequality uses
Therefore, from (4.6), (4.14), (4.15) and (4.16), we have following conclusion at in (4.10),
| (4.17) |
If (: far greater than), according to construction of and the previous estimate, we easily obtain
then, (4.17) implies that
since and depend on , , , . Consequently, we get
and for any ,
Step 2: Prove .
We consider the auxiliary function as follows
where are positive constants which will be chosen later, and denotes the maximal eigenvalue of ; for convenience, we write for .
For every fixed , suppose is attained at point . By a rotation of coordinates, we may assume
Hence, in order to show , that is to prove By means of the above assumption, we transform into the following form,
Utilizing again the above assumption, for any fixed , has a local maximum at , thus, we have at ,
| (4.18) | ||||
and
At , we also have
From Eq. (3) and (2.5), we know that
| (4.19) |
Let
Differentiating (4.19) once and twice, we respectively get
and
By the Ricci identity, we have
Thus, we can derive
Recall
since is a constant factor, we have . Consequently, we may obtain following form by and (4.18),
Recall (4.5)
then,
| (4.20) |
where , ,
| (4.21) |
from , we get
| (4.22) |
Thus, from Lemma 4.3, (4.6), (4.20), (4.21) and (4.22), we get
| (4.23) |
where
| (4.24) |
From (4.22), we get
This combined with (4.18) implies
| (4.25) |
5. The convergence of the flow
With the help of priori estimates in the section 4, the long-time existence and asymptotic behaviour of the flow (1) (or (3)) are obtained, we also can complete proof of Theorem 1.6.
Proof of the Theorem 1.6.
Since Eq. (3) is parabolic, we can get its short time existence. Let be the maximal time such that is a smooth even solution to Eq. (3) for . Lemma 4.3-4.5 enable us to apply Lemma 4.6 to Eq. (3), thus, we can deduce a uniformly upper and lower bounds for the biggest eigenvalue of . This implies
where independents on . This shows that Eq. (3) is uniformly parabolic. Estimates for higher derivatives follows from the standard regularity theory of uniformly parabolic equations Krylov [17]. Hence, we obtain the long time existence and regularity of solutions for the flow (1) (or (3)). Moreover, we obtain
| (5.1) |
for some ( are nonnegative integers pairs) independent of , then . Using parabolic comparison principle, we can attain the uniqueness of the smooth even solution of Eq. (3).
Now, recall the non-increasing property of in Lemma 3.2, we know that for ,
In view of (5.1), applying the Arzel-Ascoli theorem and a diagonal argument, we can extract a subsequence of , denoted by , and there exists a smooth even function such that
| (5.3) |
uniformly for each nonnegative integer as . This reveals that is a support function. Let us denote by the convex body determined by . Thus, is smooth, origin-symmetric and strictly convex.
Moreover, by (5.1) and the uniform estimates in section 4, we conclude that is a bounded function in and is uniformly continuous. Thus, for any , by monotonicity of the in Lemma 3.2, there is a constant independents of , such that
this gives
| (5.4) |
The left hand side of (5.4) is bounded below by , therefore, there is a subsequence such that
The proof of Lemma 3.2 shows that when ,
| (5.5) |
and ,
| (5.6) |
where is the support function of . By equality condition of HΓΆlder inequality, (5.5) and (5.6) means that for ,
| (5.7) |
and ,
| (5.8) |
(5.7) satisfies (1.8) and (5.8) satisfies (1.10) with and given by
and
This completes the proof of Theorem 1.6. β
References
- [2] B. Andrews, P. F. Guan and L. Ni, Flow by powers of the Gauss curvature, Adv. Math., 299 (2016), 174-201.
- [3] K. J. Boroczky, E. Lutwak, D. Yang and G. Y. Zhang, The logarithmic Minkowski problem, Amer. Math. Soc., 26 (2013), 831-852.
- [4] S. Brendle, K. Choi and P. Daskalopoulos, Asymptotic behavior of flows by powers of the Gaussian curvature, Acta Math., 219 (2017), 1-16.
- [5] P. Bryan, M. N. Ivaki and J. Scheuer, A unified flow approach to smooth, even -Minkowski problems, Anal. PDE, 12 (2019), 259-280.
- [6] C. Q. Chen, Y. Huang and Y. M. Zhao, Smooth solution to the dual Minkowski problem, Math. Ann., 373 (2019), 953-976.
- [7] H. D. Chen and Q. R. Li, The dual Minkowski problem and related parabolic flows, J. Funct. Anal., 281 (2021), 1-65.
- [8] K. S. Chou and X. J. Wang, A logarithmic Gauss curvature flow and the Minkowski problem, Ann. Inst. H. PoincarΓ© Anal. Non LinΓ©aire, 17 (2000), 733-751.
- [9] Y. B. Feng, S. N. Hu and L. Xu, On the Gaussian Minkowski problem, J. Differential Equation, 363 (2023), 350-390.
- [10] W. J. Firey, Shapes of worn stones, Mathematika, 21 (1974), 1-11.
- [11] L. J. Guo, D. M. Xi and Y. M. Zhao, The chord Minkowski problem in a critical interval, Math. Ann., (2023), DOI:org/10.1007/s00208-023-02721-8.
- [12] C. Haberl and F. E. Schuster, Asymmetric affine Sobolev inequalities, J. Funct. Anal., 257 (2009), 641-658.
- [13] J. R. Hu, Y. Huang and J. Lu, On the regularity of the chord log-Minkowski problem, (2023), arXiv:2304.14220.
- [14] J. R. Hu, Y. Huang, J. Lu and S. N. Wang, The chord Gauss curvature flow and its chord Minkowski problem, (2023), arXiv:2305.00453.
- [15] Y. Huang and L. Qin, The Gaussian chord Minkowksi problem, Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. Ser. S, (2023), DOI:10.3934/dcdss.2023118.
- [16] Y. Huang, D. M. Xi and Y. M. Zhao, The Minkowski problem in Gaussian probability space, Adv. Math., 385 (2021), 1-36.
- [17] N. V. Krylov, Nonlinear elliptic and parabolic equations of the second order, Dordrecht, Holland: D. Reidel Publishing Company, 1987.
- [18] Q. R. Li, W. M. Sheng and X. J. Wang, Flow by Gauss curvature to the Aleksandrov and dual Minkowski problems, J. Eur. Math. Soc., 22 (2019), 893-923.
- [19] Y. Y. Li, The chord Minkowski problem for negative p, J. Geom. Anal., (2024), DOI.org/10.1007/s12220-023-01528-y.
- [20] J. Q. Liu, The -Gaussian Minkowski problem, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations, 61 (2022), 1-23.
- [21] Y. N. Liu and J. Lu, A flow method for the dual Orlicz-Monkowski problem, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 373 (2020), 5833-5853.
- [22] Y. N. Liu and J. Lu, A generalized Gauss curvature flow related to the Orlicz-Minkowski problem, arXiv:2005.02376.
- [23] E. Lutwak, The Brunn-Minkowski-Firey theory. I. Mixed volumes and the Minkowski problem, J. Differential Geom., 38 (1993), 131-150.
- [24] E. Lutwak, D. Yang and G. Y. Zhang, Sharp affine Sobolev inequalities, J. Differential Geom., 62 (2002), 17-38.
- [25] E. Lutwak, D. M. Xi, D. Yang and G. Y. Zhang, Chord measures in integral geometry and their Minkowski problems, Comm. Pure Appl. Math., (2023), DOI: 10.1002/cpa.22190.
- [26] L. Qin, Nonlocal energies of convex bodies and their -Minkowski problems, Adv. Math., 427 (2023), 1-19.
- [27] R. Schneider, Convex bodies: the Brunn-Minkowski theory, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2014.
- [28] K. Tso, Deforming a hypersurface by its Gauss-Kronecker curvature, Comm. Pure Appl. Math., 38 (1985), 867-882.
- [29] J. I. E. Urbas, An expansion of convex hypersurfaces, J. Differential Geom., 33 (1991), 91-125.
- [30] W. M. Sheng and K. Xue, Flow by Gauss curvature to the -Gaussian Minkowski problem, (2022), arXiv:2212.01822.
- [31] D. M. Xi, D. Yang, G. Y. Zhang and Y. M. Zhao, The chord Minkowski problem, Adv. Nonlinear Stud., 23 (2023), 20220041.
- [32] J. Xiao, Prescribing capacitary curvature measures on planar convex domains, J. Geom. Anal., 30 (2020), 2225-2240.
- [33] X. Zhao and P. B. Zhao, Flow by Gauss curvature to the orlicz chord Minkowski problem, Ann. Mat. Pura Appl., (2024), DOI.org/10.1007/s10231-024-01448-w.
- [34] G. X. Zhu, The centro-affine Minkowksi problem, J. Differential Geom., 101 (2015), 159-174.